
The Magic Idea Box
I began my book as a pantster. I had the inciting incident well mapped out in my head, notions of who these characters were and how they were all related, and a few ideas that might work for the ending. But I didn’t have an outline or a well-defined plot by any stretch of the imagination. I loved the way each writing session brought new and exciting scenes into existence out of thin air.
Sometimes it was a battle to locate the exact words needed to construct each sentence, but the momentum built and I felt like my story was going places. In fact, my brain started sending me flashes of places the characters could go, phrases they could use, ways they could interact… until it all started to feel muddled and I was afraid I would lose these little flashes of inspiration.
Committing to the Notebook
I went to the bookstore and bought myself a small black notebook with a flexible cover, one that was portable enough to stick in the sleeve with my netbook to keep with me for writing sessions. I decided I needed to start writing things down, starting with the daily specials at the bakery above which my main character lived.
I made a page for each character and filled it with both pertinent and irrelevant details about their lives and personalities. I divided the book into sections, and the last two-thirds I devoted to “What Happens Next”, where I jotted down notes about potential scenes as they came to me. I did this for about a week, trying to nail down an outline that I could use as a structure for writing the rest of the book.
I wouldn’t say it was a waste of time… ok, it was a waste of time. When I went back to start writing, the organic way my story evolved moved it out of the realm of the outline in a matter of days and into scenes I hadn’t thought of. The first third of my notebook, the reference part, was useful, but the last section was increasingly meaningless with each word I typed.
Yet I was still afraid of losing those little bits of inspiration.
Enter the Recipe Cards
I decided that a non-linear approach would work better for capturing these ideas. I got a set of little 3×5 cue cards (recipe cards) on which I wrote one sentence describing the main action or point of a scene, or a decision made by a character, or a line of dialogue that popped into my head. I put them in a lovely little black-and-white box, and every so often I would spread them out on the kitchen counter and move them around into possible plot sequences.
I highlighted those that I knew I MUST have in the book, but there were many “this might happen” or “this would be clever” bits that never made their way into the story. It was still helpful to move them around and place them in between the must-haves – even if I never told those bits of story, I knew that they had happened to my characters and it changed how they related to each other.
I would write organically for a couple of weeks and then go back to the box, open it up and see if there was anything I could use or anything I’d forgotten. I’d jot down any ideas I’d had that the book wasn’t yet ready for. And then I would put the little box back on the shelf and go back to the business of stringing paragraphs together to get on with telling the story.
Magic Idea Box
Eventually, as I neared the end of my book, I had such a clear vision of what was meant to happen that I rarely opened my little magic idea box. It’s still sitting on a shelf in my bedroom. I’m almost afraid to open it in case there was some clever bit that I wrote on a card that I never did manage to work into my novel.
Oh well. Maybe there’s something I can use in the next one.
What about you – are you a hybrid writer like me? Do you outline meticulously or only once you get in over your head so you don’t forget things?